Black Buttercream Recipe

Hi guys. i’m Sarah Joseph. today on Ella Velvet Bakes. we are going to master black buttercream. I’m going to show you two ways to make black buttercream recipe. the first one I’m going to be working on is going to change the flavor. i’m working with 2 cups of my vanilla buttercream. and all this in my buttercream is a butter, imagine that, icing sugar, milk, and pure vanilla extract. We’re going to add in a little bit of cocoa powder. which is going to change the flavor.

Equipment For Black Buttercream Recipe

• Large mixing bowl
• Hand mixer or stand mixer
• Rubber spatula
• Measuring cups
• Measuring cup for cocoa powder
• Piping bags
• 1M piping tip (or any piping tip)
• Jar or tall glass (to hold the piping bag while filling)
• Piping bag tie or elastic band
• Offset spatula (optional)

---

Ingredients For Black Buttercream Recipe

• 2 cups vanilla buttercream
• ⅓ cup cocoa powder (for chocolate version)
• Black gel food coloring (Super Black gel paste)
• Chocolate brown gel food coloring (for vanilla version)

Vanilla Buttercream Contains:

• Butter
• Icing sugar (powdered sugar)
• Milk
• Pure vanilla extract

---

My second way of making the black buttercream is going to be without the cocoa. So if you are a chocolate hater, or you have an order for somebody who doesn’t want any chocolate, don’t worry. I’m going to show you a second way to do that too.

So I put about a third of a cup of cocoa powder into here, and I’m just going to start stirring it and kind of mixing it in with my spatula. Because if you’ve ever tried to work with a mixer or a hand mixer with a really light powder, you know what happens when you turn it on too fast. You get a big huge puff and a big huge disaster in the kitchen.

So I’m just going to slowly mix it in, and then I’m going to continue to mix it with my mixer. We’ve got enough here now. Obviously, if you don’t have a hand mixer, you can just do your buttercream completely like this with a spatula. But a mixer does make it a little bit easier and a little bit quicker.

Now, fingers crossed. Hopefully I don’t get a big disaster. I’m going to mix this up completely.

For this version, adding the cocoa powder is going to give us a brown base to start our black buttercream. Obviously, it does change the flavor, like I was mentioning. And this is also how you make chocolate buttercream. So there you go. Another bonus recipe in here.

So what we’re going to be working with is a black gel paste. This is AmeriColor Super Black Gel Paste. All gel paste colors are basically just concentrated coloring. They’re not like liquid food coloring. They’re much stronger, so you don’t have to add in as much as you might with a black liquid coloring.

As far as I know, we can’t get black liquid coloring where I live in Canada. So I’ve only ever used the gel paste for black, and it works perfectly for me every time.

So what we’re going to do is open up the little bottle here, squeeze in some of that gel paste, and then we’re going to mix that in again with our beaters.

So I’ve come to a color that’s mostly a dark, dark, dark gray. It’s close to black, but not quite as dark as I want it to be.

So what I’m going to do is add in another squeeze of my gel.

Now, people sometimes complain about the taste of buttercream changing to be more bitter, and that’s often from using too much gel paste. What you can find is that when you add the chocolate first, it’s going to counteract that bitterness. You’re also not going to need as much of the gel paste as you would if you didn’t start out with that dark base.

So I’m going to whip this part up and mix in this next bit of black gel.

My buttercream has been sitting for about 20 minutes, and it’s a beautiful dark black shade. If you leave your icing to sit, the gel paste will eventually become more saturated within your icing, and you’re going to get a deeper color the longer you let it sit.

Now over here I have a piping bag, and it’s fitted with a 1M piping tip. But you can use any tip inside your piping bag.

For support, I just have the piping bag sitting inside a jar, and that helps me fill the bag much more easily.

Take a little bit of the buttercream from your spatula, wipe it into the jar, and press it against the rim of the jar. That helps get the buttercream into your piping bag much more easily.

You can absolutely do this while holding the piping bag if you’re comfortable with it, but this little trick makes the job much easier.

Then I’m going to pull this part up and shape it down. After that, I’m going to squeeze the icing down toward the tip.

While I’m doing that, I’m locking the icing into the bag by twisting the top. Then I’m going to take a piping bag tie, basically just an elastic, wrap it around the top, and that’s going to help prevent any of the icing from squeezing out of the top of the bag.

So we’re going to use this to pipe a black swirl onto our cupcakes.

---

Baking Tips For Black Buttercream Recipe

1. Let the Buttercream Rest

After mixing in the food coloring, let the buttercream sit for at least 20 minutes. The color will deepen naturally as it rests.

2. Start with a Dark Base

Mix cocoa powder or brown gel coloring into the buttercream before adding black food coloring. This helps you achieve a rich black color with less food coloring.

3. Use Gel Food Coloring

Gel food coloring is much more concentrated than liquid food coloring, so you’ll need less and the buttercream won’t become runny.

4. Avoid Adding Too Much Black Coloring

Too much black gel coloring can leave a bitter taste. Using cocoa powder or brown gel coloring first helps reduce the amount of black coloring needed.

See This Also – How to Make Eggless Swiss Meringue Buttercream (Smooth, Creamy & Easy Recipe)

---

Popular Black Buttercream Methods and Variations

There are many ways to make black buttercream, and each method produces slightly different results. Some bakers prefer a classic black buttercream recipe made with black gel food coloring, while others use cocoa powder to create a darker base before adding color.

Black Buttercream With Cocoa Powder

One of the most popular methods is making black buttercream with cocoa powder. Cocoa powder gives the frosting a naturally darker starting point, which means less black food coloring is needed. Many bakers searching for how to make black buttercream with cocoa powder use regular unsweetened cocoa powder or black cocoa powder to achieve a deeper shade.

How to Make Black Buttercream Without Black Cocoa

Not everyone has black cocoa powder in their pantry. The good news is that you can still learn how to make black buttercream without black cocoa by starting with a standard vanilla buttercream and gradually adding concentrated black food coloring. Allowing the buttercream to rest for several hours can help the color develop into a richer black shade.

Black Buttercream Microwave Method

Some decorators use the black buttercream microwave method to deepen the color quickly. This technique involves briefly heating a portion of the buttercream, mixing it back into the batch, and allowing the color to intensify. While this method can help darken the frosting faster, many bakers still prefer the traditional resting method for consistent results.

Over the Top Black Buttercream

The Over the Top black buttercream method is another popular approach among cake decorators. This technique focuses on building a dark base color first and then using black food coloring to create a dramatic black finish suitable for modern cake designs and Halloween desserts.

Sugarologie Black Buttercream Method

The Sugarologie black buttercream technique has become popular because it focuses on color development and ingredient selection to achieve a deep black shade with less food coloring. Many bakers compare this approach with traditional black frosting methods to determine which works best for their decorating style.

Homemade Black Buttercream vs. Store-Bought Options

While homemade frosting gives you complete control over flavor and consistency, some bakers look for black buttercream to buy when they need a quick decorating solution. Ready-made black frosting can save time, but homemade buttercream often provides better control over texture and freshness.

If you are shopping online, you may also come across black buttercream Amazon listings that offer pre-made frosting, food coloring, and decorating supplies. However, making your own black buttercream allows you to adjust the color, sweetness, and consistency to match your project.

Best Black Buttercream Recipe Tips

If you are looking for the best black buttercream recipe, focus on three key factors: starting with a darker base, using concentrated black food coloring, and allowing the buttercream to rest before adding more coloring.

These simple steps can help transform gray frosting into rich black frosting without using excessive amounts of food coloring.

Black Cocoa Powder and Black Buttercream

Black cocoa powder is often used by bakers because it creates an extremely dark starting color. Although it is not required, black cocoa powder can help achieve a deep black buttercream with less food coloring.

It is especially useful for chocolate-flavored cakes, cookies, and cupcakes where a darker frosting is desired.

The final result will still depend on the butter, powdered sugar, cocoa powder, food coloring, mixing time, resting time, and temperature. That is why testing the color of your own batch is one of the best ways to achieve the shade you want.

---

Frequently Asked Questions For Black Buttercream Recipe

Why won’t my buttercream turn black?

Black buttercream usually starts as dark gray. Let it rest for 20–60 minutes, and the color will deepen significantly.

Can I make black buttercream without cocoa powder?

Yes. Use chocolate brown gel food coloring first, then gradually add black gel food coloring. This keeps the buttercream vanilla flavored.

Does black food coloring change the taste?

It can if you use too much. Starting with cocoa powder or brown gel coloring reduces the amount of black coloring required and helps prevent bitterness.

Which food coloring works best?

A concentrated black gel food coloring works best because it provides a deep color without thinning the buttercream.

Black Buttercream Recipe – Quick Recap